August 26:
• "Deer are not fond of peppermint. The strong scent overwhelms their senses, making it an effective deterrent."
The deer at the greenhouse finally did it. They crossed the Rubicon and sampled all three peppermint pots. I posted the following "Lies from the Internet" June 28 and have been adding to it ever since. The lies are that certain plants are resistant to deer, and peppermint always is at the top of the "resistant" list. I have two other peppermint plants at the house a mile from the greenhouse. The local deer have not sampled those. They are a bit darker green than the three shown below, and they are flowering. Whether the scent is more intense and they avoid them for that reason, or whether the local deer just have different taste, I do not know.
The greenhouse deer took another nip in the past couple of days at the Monarda, chives, Vermillionaire, salvias, zinnias and marigolds, all of which also are on the list. At the house, they tried but mostly failed to push through a cage to get at the Astilbe, apparently unaware that "The smell, texture, and bitter taste of astilbe flowers are distasteful to deer."
My list of truly deer resistant plants includes Plectranthus 'Velveteen Aromatic' (incorrectly known as Cuban Oregano), Garden Sage, Russian Sage, Rosemary, Greek Oregano (not Italian), Thyme, Agastache, Lavendar, and most succulents including Sempervivums and Echeverias (not Delosperma and Aloe). That's it, that's the list.
August 19:
• Actually I can't call this one a lie because the internet hedges: "Basil is considered moderately deer resistant. Deer generally dislike its strong aroma and essential oils, but it is not completely deer-proof."
I got home from a week away today and the greenhouse deer decimated the two basil plants that were outside. (They also chewed the flowers off all of the deer-resistant marigolds. And they destroyed the zinnias for the hundredth time. I got NO zinnia flowers this year.) The deer at the house a mile away have not touched three basil plants that are outside. I'll probably secure the largest one just in case their cousins from down the road turn them on to basil.
August 8:
• Today's lie is about phlox. "Looking to add a pop of color that butterflies love but deer won’t touch? Meet phlox—your new favorite flowering perennial."
We have two plants next to the house that have been there for six years but have never flowered because the deer keep chewing on them. I identified them today with 68% certainty that they are phlox. I put cages around them a month or so ago and they have been growing well, so we will see if we get anything this year. August 24: The deer bent the cage and chewed through the wire to take out one side of the one of the plants. Phlox isn't just a target of opportunity; they were working to get at it.
July 27:
• "Delosperma (hardy ice plant) is considered exceptionally deer resistant. Deer typically pass on these vibrant mat-forming succulents."
WRONG!!! I put one of my Delosperma outside the greenhouse to get it some more sun, hoping it would finally flower. The deer knocked over the pot in their haste to chomp on it. It got a good pruning but will survive...inside.
• "Nasturtiums are generally considered deer-resistant because of their spicy scent, peppery taste, and pungent oils."
WRONG!!! The nasturtiums growing in my greenhouse window box were consumed by deer in the past 24 hours.
Also today, the deer confirmed that they will eat Coleus (see below). My two larger Coleus 'Wicked Witch' pots have not been touched at the house, but the deer around the greenhouse ate the two smaller ones I had there, following up on an incident a month ago. One or both might bounce back eventually. I'm still waiting for the supposed toxicity of Coleus to kick in and take out some of the herd, but that may be wishful thinking. There may be a difference in acquired taste in the two deer herds a mile apart, but in light of recent events at the greenhouse I feel compelled to cage the two big 'Wicked Witch' at the house. August 24: I left one of the 'Wicked Witch' on the patio without a cage. It was surrounded by stinky plants like peppermint and oregano, but that was no deterrent. It will recover eventually. I moved the pristine one into Witness Protection inside the greenhouse for the remainder of the summer.
There were five deer around the lodge today, three adults and two fawns. I would walk toward them making threatening moves, and they would just stare at me. If I got too close, they would jog about 20 yards and look back at me. Truly town deer.
This just in: The deer at the house lopped the top off of our Stevia plant. But to be fair, Stevia is not considered deer resistant.
June 28 original post:
• "Borage is highly deer-resistant. Its sprawling foliage and stems are covered in rough, bristly hairs that deer and rabbits tend to avoid."
WRONG!!! They ate a borage plant and half of a strawberry plant in a caged grow bag in the yard. Fortunately, I was already planning to remove that borage so a strawberry runner from an adjacent grow bag could root there. The other bag had a slightly taller cage and escaped unscathed. The strawberry plant might bounce back. I put a netting over the top of both cages and still should be able to root the runner there. Growing borage with strawberries is supposed to have a number of benefits which I'm not going to go into. Here is an image of a borage (with strawberry plants at its feet) inside the greenhouse where the deer can't get it. Note the plastic bars set up to keep them from poking their heads in if I leave the window open. Looks like I have to add a couple more bars near the top.
• "Black-Eyed Susans (Rudbeckia) are considered deer-resistant. Deer generally avoid them because of their rough, hairy texture and strong taste."
WRONG!!! They dove down into the two-foot cage and lopped off the top. It might come back. I will put netting over the top of the cage.
• "Yes, aloe vera is generally deer-resistant. Deer typically avoid it because of its thick, spiky leaves and bitter sap."
WRONG WRONG WRONG!!! Surrounded by acres of lush early-summer vegetation, deer at the greenhouse have sampled aloe vera on two different occasions. I'm leaving some aloe vera outside the greenhouse as an act of defiance, and in hopes that the reported toxicity will kick in and take care of the problem. Deer at the house (a mile away) have not sampled the aloe vera. July 1 update: The deer at the greenhouse chewed on both of the 'Tiger Tooth' aloes. As mentioned, they have their choice of lush vegetation the area, but they decided to sample plants with sharp spines. It would be like chewing on razor blades. This is ridiculous. At the house, a deer was seen sniffing an aloe vera on the back deck, so now all aloe at both locations are inside. The six at the greenhouse are lined up at the back of the bench because they are big, and to stay out of direct light. I noticed that all six have chunks missing. The two at the house made it inside sniffed but unscathed.
• "Yes, Monarda (commonly known as Bee Balm or Bergamot) is widely considered reliably deer-resistant. Deer typically avoid it due to its strong, medicinal, mint-like fragrance and slightly fuzzy leaf texture."
WRONG!!! They sampled a Monarda I bought and planted at the corner of our house. It will bounce back eventually, but that set it back significantly. I'm planning on planting next to the shed the two Monardas I have nurtured from seed since late winter, killing millions of aphids to get to this point. Right now they are aphid free and more than a foot tall. But I was waiting to plant until I got more fencing material, which I now have. We also have a landscaping project coming up and it includes three Monardas. (Update: They have been caged.) The deer at the greenhouse have not chewed on the purchased Monarda that is the centerpiece of the outside barrel. They prefer aloe vera 'Tiger Tooth' aloe.
• "Yes, Salvia (sage) is widely considered an exceptionally deer-resistant plant. Deer typically avoid it because of its strong, aromatic fragrance and slightly fuzzy, textured leaves, which they find highly unappealing."
• "Vermillionaire® (Cuphea hybrid), also known as the Large Firecracker Plant, is highly deer-resistant. Its tubular flowers have an unappealing texture and a strong, unpalatable scent that grazing deer typically avoid."
WRONG!!! I planted a salvia and a Vermillionaire together in a grow bag and the deer couldn't wait to take the tops off of them that night. The salvia recovered sooner than the Vermillionaire, but neither is near its original height.
• "Yes, coleus are generally considered deer-resistant. Their textured leaves, strong natural scents, and the plant's mild toxicity make them unappealing to browsing deer."
WRONG!!! The greenhouse deer chewed on two coleus which I had outside. Fortunately they didn't completely destroy them and they have regrown from the stubs.
• "Oregano is highly deer-resistant."
MAYBE!!! I'm not 100% sure, but I think they sampled my new Italian Oregano plant. I won't even let them have a chance at the marjoram, which is milder. They have left the more robust Greek Oregano alone.
• "Yes, marigolds are generally considered deer resistant. Deer typically avoid them due to their pungent, medicinal odor and bitter-tasting foliage."
• "Yes, chives are highly deer resistant. Because they belong to the Allium (onion) family, they have a strong smell and pungent taste that deer instinctively avoid."
WRONG??? If they yank marigolds or chives out of the pot but don't actually eat them, does that mean they are deer resistant? Last year they pulled the marigolds out of the window boxes and spit them out. They were intact enough to replant. A couple months later, they did it again. It was too late in the year to bother replanting them. This year I planted the nastiest marigolds I could find, and they have left them alone. Also this year, they yanked a chive plant out of its pot and spit it out. I replanted it and it probably will be OK. August 25: I'm updating this from "WRONG???" to "WRONG!!!" They are definitely searching out the marigolds to eat the flower buds, and they are clipping the chives like grass.
• "Zinnias are considered moderately deer resistant. While deer generally avoid the coarse texture and strong scent of mature zinnia plants, they will happily eat tender young seedlings or the flowers if their preferred food sources are scarce."
Right (mostly)!!! What I disagree with here is other food sources are not scarce! They took out two of my six zinnia seedlings that were about four inches high in the window boxes, ignoring acres of lush vegetation surrounding them. August 26: I have about five zinnia sprouts in the window boxes that haven't gotten taller than four inches all summer. Any time one develops a flower bud, they eat it.
Usually these internet statements are accompanied by a disclaimer that deer will eat just about anything if that's all they have or if there is a drought. For the record, both my house and the greenhouse are surrounded by lush fields of vegetation that have received adequate rainfall this spring and early summer. They have no excuse. They are 150-lb. rodents.
So far the plants the deer have not touched are Agastache, Basil, Lavender, Greek Oregano, Rosemary, Sage, Russian Sage, Peppermint, Sempervivums, Thyme, and Plectranthus 'Velveteen Aromatic'™. I have 20 fuzzy, aromatic 'Velveteen' plants scattered around outside and they don't touch them. They also haven't touched my petunias...but they are in baskets eight feet in the air.
On a more positive note, it appears two of the four potato stalks are in the process of dying. They have leaned over quite a bit just since yesterday. That might mean the harvest is not too far away. We are just about at the 90-day mark, so apparently we are on track. They have not flowered, but flowering is not a required step to get a harvest. I'm excited, not just for the potatoes, but for getting that big grow bag out of the greenhouse where the plants overshadow their neighbors.
I don't plan on growing potatoes inside the greenhouse next year, but I might put the big grow bag in our yard next to our new trees, and the question is whether I have to fence it. "Yes, potato plants are generally considered deer resistant. Deer typically avoid grazing on them because the leaves are part of the nightshade family and contain bitter toxins (glycoalkaloids) that are unappealing." I like the part about the toxins, but I probably will fence them at least initially. Red Lodge deer have made a liar of the internet too many times for me to lower my guard.






























